The real estate industry is facing a harsh new reality – one that has nothing to do with interest rates or home prices. It’s a trust recession, and it’s hitting us hard. Simply put, consumers don’t trust real estate agents like they used to. In fact, a recent survey found 67.5% of Americans don’t trust real estate agents (source). That’s more than two-thirds of our potential clients starting from a place of skepticism. You can feel it in the air: people are screening calls, side-eyeing ads, and generally tuning out the traditional sales pitch.

Have you noticed prospects dodging your calls or ignoring your emails? You’re not alone. Consumers today are picking up the phone a lot less often – and who can blame them? They’re bombarded by robocalls and spam daily. Over two-thirds of people admit they’ve ignored or declined calls they wanted to take because they didn’t trust the caller info, and a whopping 86% refuse to answer unknown numbers altogether (source). In other words, cold calling is on life support. The old playbook of “dial until they buy” is falling flat in an era where buyer skepticism and information overload rule the day (source).

Meanwhile, there are more agents than ever chasing fewer deals. The industry has been flooded with licensees (around two million in the U.S. alone) (source), which means competition for each client is brutal. When everyone is desperate to close a sale, the noise level goes up – and trust plummets. Consumers feel like everywhere they turn, another agent is trying to sell them something. They’re tired of it. They’re tired of canned scripts, hard sells, and generic mailers. It’s no surprise their default response is “ignore” or “no, thanks.” As one industry commentator put it, the market has shifted and many of the older tactics – cold calls, mass emails, generic lead-gen – are now falling short of expectations (source). We’re seeing slower pipelines, higher marketing costs, and diminishing returns on the old approaches. The cold truth is that the trust gap between agents and consumers has never been wider.

Why Buyers and Sellers Are Fed Up with Traditional Tactics

This “trust recession” didn’t happen overnight. It’s been brewing for years as consumers gained access to more information and options. Think about it: today’s buyers and sellers can look up home values online, read agent reviews, and educate themselves with a few clicks. They don’t need to tolerate pushy sales tactics – and they won’t. The problem with our old-school methods is that they prioritize quick hits and lead quantity over genuine value or trust, which are exactly what modern clients are looking for (source). We’ve been taught to flood the zone with ads, blast out cold emails, work the phones, and always be closing. But if everyone’s doing that, it all becomes noise.

Consider the traditional lead generation model: buy a list or run some flashy Facebook ads, get a pile of leads, then hammer away hoping a few say yes. Even when it “works,” how often did those leads turn out to be unqualified or not ready? All too often. Agents end up spending hours chasing dead ends – calling folks who aren’t truly interested or who treat us like an unwelcome nuisance (source). It’s exhausting, and it burns through our time and money. More importantly, it erodes the profession’s credibility. Every aggressive cold call or spammy postcard that annoys a consumer doesn’t just hurt one agent’s reputation – it makes the entire profession a little less trusted.

Buyers and sellers today are over the hype. They can smell a sales pitch a mile away, and they’re jaded from years of being “sold to.” What they want (and rarely find) is someone who will listen and guide them – a trusted advisor, not a slick salesperson (source). If you’ve ever had a client come to you after dealing with another agent, you’ve probably heard horror stories: “That last agent only cared about her commission,” or “All he did was pressure me to sign.” The appetite for genuine guidance is huge, and that’s the silver lining in this trust recession. Yes, trust is at an all-time low – but that just means the agent who can build trust has a massive advantage.

The New Strategy: Stop Selling and Start Educating

If you’re reading this and nodding along, you’re likely wondering how to turn things around. How do you get people to trust you before you’ve even spoken to them? The answer is both simple and game-changing: stop pushing the hard sell, and start educating your prospects. In a world full of pushy agents, the shortest path to trust is to offer value with no strings attached. Think of it as giving before asking. When you share useful knowledge freely – with honesty and authenticity – people can’t help but start seeing you as an expert and someone who genuinely cares.

This isn’t just fluffy marketing talk; it’s a proven approach that’s working right now. Educating prospects flips the script of traditional sales. Instead of you qualifying them, they begin to qualify you – and in a good way. They see you as an authority because you’re teaching them something valuable, not begging for business. One sales expert in the financial world observed that your prospects are now assessing you first, which means you have to differentiate yourself by offering insight, not just credentials (source). In plain terms, to stand out, you need to become a trusted real estate advisor, not just another agent. That requires an entirely different approach – one that’s more pull than push.

Focus on the problems your clients are trying to solve, and speak directly to those issues. First-time buyers confused about the mortgage process? Upsizers nervous about selling and buying in the same market? Whatever the pain point, address it head-on with useful information. This positions you as a specialist who “gets it.” As industry coaches often say, don’t pitch yourself – prove yourself. Your marketing should feel like you’ve read the client’s mind and you’re offering help, not like you’re reading off a script about yourself (source). When you do this right, something amazing happens: clients start to trust you before that first one-on-one conversation. By the time you meet, they’re leaning in, not pulling away.

One of the most powerful ways to put this educate-first strategy into action is through webinars. Yes, you heard that right – webinars. They might sound old-school (or overly techy for some), but in today’s climate webinars are a secret weapon for building trust at scale.

Webinars: A Powerful Trust-Building Tool (That Most Agents Ignore)

Imagine being able to get in front of 50 motivated buyers or sellers at once and actually have them listen to you. No chasing, no cold calling – they voluntarily showed up to hear your advice. That’s the beauty of a webinar. It’s essentially a modern, virtual seminar, and it’s working wonders for those agents savvy enough to use it. Webinars allow you to educate many people at once, delivering your expertise to a wide audience in one sitting. Instead of repeating yourself in ten separate buyer consultations, you host one online workshop that answers the top 10 questions buyers (or sellers) ask. The efficiency is unbeatable, and so is the impact on your credibility.

Here’s why webinars are game-changers in a trust-starved market:

• You provide real value upfront: A webinar forces you to give before you get. By sharing knowledge – for example, “5 Secrets to Selling Your Home in a Slow Market” – you’re building goodwill and authority. Attendees walk away feeling educated, not sold, and they’ll remember who helped them understand the process. These webinars are designed to build trust and authority by providing value upfront, with zero hard sales pitch (source). You become the teacher, and that automatically elevates you above the run-of-the-mill agent.
• One-to-many efficiency: In just an hour or two, you can meaningfully engage dozens of prospects. Many agents are already seeing around 60 people attend a single session, with roughly 20% of those attendees booking a follow-up call afterward (source). Do the math – that could be 10–15 qualified appointments from one webinar. And you didn’t have to cold call a single person to get them. With webinars, agents are attracting higher-quality leads, reducing wasted time, and closing more deals (source). It’s the ultimate leverage of your time.
• Attendees come in warmed up: Remember, these folks signed up for your webinar voluntarily – they want the information you’re offering. That means by the time you speak with them one-on-one, they’re already semi-sold on you. They’ve heard your voice, gotten a taste of your expertise, and begun to trust you. In marketing terms, this is inbound lead generation at its finest. One brokerage consulting firm reports that after adopting an education-based webinar funnel, agents were able to stop chasing leads and instead attract clients who were genuinely ready to buy or sell (source). How nice does that sound?
• You position yourself as the expert (while others are just salespeople): Running a webinar – especially if none of your competitors are doing it – instantly differentiates you. It signals that you’re serious enough to host an event to help consumers, not just splash your face on bus benches. Most agents aren’t prioritizing education for their clients, which is exactly why those who do gain a competitive edge (source). When a prospect attends your session and learns something new, you’ve set yourself apart as an advisor. Meanwhile the other agents are still cold calling (and still getting sent to voicemail).
• Higher trust = higher-quality leads: Webinars naturally filter out the tire-kickers. Think about it – if someone invests an hour to learn from you about the market or the buying process, they’re likely serious about making a move. These aren’t random internet leads half-heartedly filling out a form; they’re people who showed up and engaged. Agents using webinars have found that webinar attendees convert to clients at a much higher rate than typical leads because they’ve been pre-nurtured with content. They enter your pipeline already feeling like they know you. That “let’s hop on a call” follow-up isn’t a cold call anymore – it’s a continuation of a conversation. As one case study showed, a single webinar can yield a couple of closed deals (not just leads, actual deals) in the following weeks (source). All without any cold calls or relentless follow-ups. That is quality and efficiency personified.

Thriving by Putting Trust First

Here’s the bottom line: the market has fundamentally changed, and the old methods of drumming up business aren’t coming back (source). You can’t cold-call your way out of a trust recession. You can’t billboard or Facebook-ad your way out of it either – not without evolving your approach. The only way forward is to put trust at the center of your strategy. That means delivering value first, being patient, and building genuine relationships at scale. It might feel like a big shift if you’ve spent years doing “ABC (Always Be Closing),” but this is the new reality. And frankly, it’s a change for the better. When you lead with education and authenticity, you enjoy your marketing more (no more feeling like a pest), and you attract clients who actually appreciate you. It’s win-win.

The agents and mortgage professionals who embrace this will not only survive the current trust deficit – they’ll dominate as the market rebounds. They’ll be the ones people pick up the phone for, because their reputation precedes them. We’re already seeing it happen: savvy agents are tripling their ROI by switching from cold prospecting to content-driven, trust-focused marketing (source). They’re working smarter, not harder, and building businesses that last. You can do the same.

If you’re feeling overwhelmed at the prospect of reinventing your marketing, take heart. You don’t have to go it alone. In fact, there are already playbooks out there for exactly this kind of trust-based, webinar-driven strategy. (One firm, RECODemand, has helped over 400 agents implement webinar funnels and triple their webinar ROI (source).) The resources and support exist to guide you through the shift from old-school tactics to this new, more effective model.

The cold truth is that we are indeed in a trust recession – but your personal business doesn’t have to participate in it. Change the way you approach your prospects and clients now. Lead with value, leverage tools like webinars to scale your reach, and make trust your brand’s currency. Do that, and you won’t just weather the current storm; you’ll emerge as a market leader on the other side. That’s the real shortcut in today’s real estate game – and it’s one anyone, rookie or veteran, can start using right now.

(At RECODemand, we’ve made it our mission to help real estate and mortgage pros navigate this new landscape. Through our webinar-based marketing systems, we focus on building trust at scale – because in today’s market, that’s what closes deals.)

‍